Community participation in the development of an improved stove in a cold region of North India

Table of Contents
Introduction Community inputs Community Co-operation Stove performance tests Technology Promotion Dissemination strategies Assessing the demand for stoves Flexibility in stove design Future Plans References

Boiling Point
Issue 42 (1999) Household energy and the environment
Article	Community participation in the development of an improved stove in a cold region of North India
Author	Rakesh Prasad

[top] [end]Introduction

In rural India, the domestic sector accounts for nearly 75% of the total energy consumed; with cooking accounting for almost 90% of household energy use. Annually, the present level of consumption of fuelwood is around 200 million tonnes (Sinha C. S. et. al.), whilst it is estimated that the annual sustainable yield of fuelwood is only about 86 million tonnes. Thus, a wide gap exists between demand and sustainable supply. At the same time, traditional stoves have serious effects on the environment and lead to high levels of indoor air pollution, which affect the health of women and children.

This paper deals with the strategies adopted in the Solan district of Himachal Pradesh for introducing an improved mud cooking stove, which has an embedded water tank. The altitude of Himachal Pradesh rises from 900m, its most prominent landmark is the perennial white snow-line on various peaks. The winters are quite severe with temperature sometimes dropping to -400C in the cold desert zone of Lahaul and Spiti districts. Thus, water and space heating are major requirements, apart from cooking (Aggarwal R, Chandel S S, 1997). The most commonly used stoves are traditional wood-burning mud stoves with efficiencies ranging from 8% to 10%. The common fuel species are pinus roxburghii, and Banj (Quercus), as well as a few other less common shrubs.

The traditional cooking stove was modified to meet the need for hot water expressed by the local community.

[top] [end]Community inputs

Initial results were obtained from a water-heating tank attached to a stove, which had been developed by a local housewife. An inbuilt water tank was -placed at the bottom of the firebox with connections to the bathroom. This design was modified to develop the TERI model of improved stove for the village. The new model was installed in a test household and monitored for one month. The design was modified several times after discussions with the households. The shape and design of the kitchen, and user preferences were considered, so that the stove design could be modified slightly to suit individual households.

Stove characteristics Two embedded water tanks (combined capacity 15 litres) one on each side of the fire box. These two tanks are connected to each other, they get their cold water supply from an overhead tank and the hot water can be drawn from a tap provided in the kitchen or the bathroom. Heat is conducted to the water tanks from the firebox, and hot water is available after igniting the stove. The tanks are covered with mud on the outside to reduce heat loss. Usually, a steam pipe is fitted to the overhead tank to vent the system. A chimney channels the smoke outside. A front damper maintains the temperature in the stove and water pipes.
Figure 1: Schematic drawing of improved stove Figure 2: Fuel consumption results for five test households

Figure 2: Fuel consumption results for five test households

[top] [end]Community Co-operation

Important factors in this project were:

the involvement of the test household in the project
their willingness to cope with repeated instructions and construction
the co-operation of household members in providing valuable ideas for modification

The next step was to install the stove in five sample households, who were enthusiastic to adopt the system and were willing to pay for it. Further performance tests were carried out during this phase. Again, the willingness of households to adopt a test technology was important in this demonstration and dissemination phase.

[top] [end]Stove performance tests

Two days were spent in making and installing the stove in each of the five households. During this time, household members were given detailed information on how the stove worked. A second visit was made after 4-5 days to show households how to use the stove. Ten to twenty days after installation, tests were carried out using improved and traditional models to compare fuel consumption and cooking time (tests were repeated); results showed that households saved both fuel (Figure 2) and cooking time (Figure 3); on average, about 45%. At the same time, users were asked what they thought about the improved model compared to their traditional stoves.

Figure 2: Fuel consumption results for five test households

Figure 3: Cooking time results (traditional and improved cooking stoves)

[top] [end]Technology Promotion

The improved stove models installed in the five households were used to demonstrate the technology to the local communities, and to provide data for technical performance assessment. To convince the village community about the benefits of the technology, the Mahila Mandal was asked to disseminate information as it was believed to have closer contact and more credibility with the community. (The Mahila Mandal is a social group, organized by women at village level for various social, economic and religious activities.)

At the same time, awareness programmes for village women were created dealing with: fuel-wood consumption; over-exploitation of resources, deforestation, health hazards from indoor pollution, and the benefits of improved cooking stove technology.

The test results from the performance surveys of the improved cooking stoves were shared with communities in neighbouring villages, who were invited to see the installed models themselves. The objective was to promote the technology in several villages and create a wider demand for the devices.

[top] [end]Dissemination strategies

The dissemination strategy used in this project was successful because of the approach it adopted. Demand for the stove was generated by successive rounds of demonstration. After the first test model was installed, households in the village were approached, and a ranked list was prepared of volunteer households who wanted to adopt the stove in the first phase. Demonstrations of these stoves generated acceptance in surrounding households, who were able to see the stoves working before they made their decision.

Figure 4: Improved stove in use

Test results were shared with neighbouring villages, and Mahila Mandal groups were engaged to inform villagers of the benefits. Awareness programmes were held to promote the technology in terms of environmental and health benefits.

[top] [end]Assessing the demand for stoves

A demand assessment survey was conducted in several villages. The residents of nearby villages could visit the households and inspect the stoves for themselves and talk to the test households before making up their minds. About 20 households adopted the technology at this stage. When more stoves were installed, additional demand was generated.

Figure 5: A lady drawing hot water from the tap connected to the stove

[top] [end]Flexibility in stove design

Another aspect of acceptance was the flexibility of the improved cooking stove. Households could have extra features installed or the system modified according to their choice if they were willing to pay the additional cost.

In all 86 rural families from the 15 small villages benefited, improving their kitchens by giving them efficient and user-friendly cooking and water-heating devices. The most visible benefit was the availability of hot water without making extra work, and there were other gains, including fuel and time saved, and reduced smoke emissions during the cooking. The technology was well received, leading to demand from other households. It was noticed that households using the improved stove benefited by having more free time and being less tired. This has a direct impact on the time and care they can devote to their children, and the quality of their kitchen environment. It is also expected to provide an annual saving of 260 tonnes of biomass in the region.

[top] [end]Future Plans

The project has now ended and the programme has been handed on to a local NGO. Stoves are now being installed by local entrepreneurs, who have found that the design is well-accepted and considered desirable by the local community. Consequently, no further modifications are planned for the stove, although increasing its overall efficiency might be possible. It is currently priced at Rs 500-600 (Rs70 = £1UK) depending on the amount of pipe-work required, and compares favourably with the cost of an equivalent metal stove.

[top] [end]References

Sinha C. S, Joshi V. 1997. Biofuel demand estimation in the rural domestic energy sector of India Rural and renewable energy: perspective from developing countries, Ramana P.V.(ed.), 128-140 pp. Tata Energy Research Institute, New Delhi.
Aggarwal R, Chandel S S. 1997. 'Thermal performance comparison of metal stove for snow bound area of Himachal Pradesh' SESI Journal, 7(1): 21-26

[top] [end]Contents: Boiling Point 42 - Household energy and the environment

Improving the environment can lead to benefits for household energy - Environmental implications of the energy ladder in rural India - Household energy and environmental rehabilitation - opportunities and challenges - Deforestation and forest degradation by commercial harvesting for firewood and charcoal in the Pacific region of Nicaragua - Effect of expanding sugar-cane farming on community woodfuel collecting areas - Workshop report on urban waste and energy in developing countries, February 24, 1998 - Is urban forestry a solution to the energy crisis of Sahelian cities - Micro solar lanterns for rural communities in Kenya - The bicycle wheel water powered battery charger - Community participation in the development of an improved stove in a cold region of North India - Commercialization of the Sewa Stove in Mali

Categories: Boiling Point 42| Improved Stoves| India| Participatory Approach

edit this page

Page created: 31 July 2007; Last edited: 20 August 2007; Version: 0
Knowledge Bank text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License.

Pagename: CommunityParticipationInTheDevelopmentOfAnImprovedStoveInAColdRegionOfNorthIndia @HEDON: ECGA