Main knowledge bank page | Recent additions | Recent changes | What links here | Categories | Category cloud
How-to guides | Organisation profiles | Project profiles
 

edit this page

Learning to listen to the poor


Table of Contents

Boiling Point
Front cover of Boiling Point issue 46
Issue 46 (2001) Household energy and the vulnerable

ArticleLearning to listen to the poor
AuthorMargaret Foster


Apprendre à écouter les pauvres

Les femmes en situation de pauvreté, souvent, ont le plus à perdre. Cette tendance est renforcée par le fait que souvent l’expertise des femmes n’est pas prise en compte. L’auteur considère les travaux antérerieurs dans ce domaine et donne un aperçu d’un manuel en cours consacré cette question. Le manuel est explicitement centré sur les atouts dont les femmes disposent et les contraintes auxquelles elles font face. L’énergie est considérée comme un facteur influençant chaque aspect de leur quotidien.

[top] [end]Introduction

Very poor people are usually women, frequently ‘invisible’ to the outside world because of socio-cultural or religious reasons. Their voices are rarely heard because they are often illiterate and they lack the confidence and status to speak out within their own communities. If outsiders reinforce this situation by ignoring women, and looking instead for expertise held by (usually better-educated) men, they risk missing out on some of the most important and relevant issues. One of these key issues is the availability of adequate, renewable, cheap and healthy energy resources.

[top] [end]Identifying the right people

Listening and talking to the right people means that outsiders can understand and enhance the existing skills held by all those with knowledge of indigenous technologies, and technical aid can be more effectively targeted. It also means that a strong and equal relationship is created with local women and men.

A training manual has been developed for use by ITDG project staff with various partners in development (1). ITDG recognises that vulnerability can only be sustainably addressed by empowering, supporting and energising those who are most at risk. The training manual aims to help field and community workers to identify and listen to under-represented resource-poor people.

[top] [end]Stakeholder analysis

Primary stakeholders are those who have the most to lose, in development projects this is often poor women. Secondary stakeholders are outsiders who are affected, but who invariably have the greater power over the outcome. Conflicts of interest are often emphasised by gender; costs, benefits and resources are rarely evenly distributed, even within the family. Using tools such as stakeholder analysis may indicate those areas of support in the field of energy which may be of value to poor women.

It is important that women’s energy needs are understood within the whole context of their lives. Their existing knowledge must be respected and used as a basis for developing the energy sector and the way in which it serves the poor.

[top] [end]Sustainable Livelihood Framework

One way to analyse existing energy use or to compare alternatives is through the Sustainable Livelihood Framework (2). This method begins by considering the strengths that even the poorest people possess. These previously ignored but valuable ‘assets’, include all the important existing resources and initiatives already held by poor people, and which currently sustain them. Helen Appleton for example reported on the importance of women’s invisible technical abilities in ensuring household food security(3). The Framework can be used to highlight those aspects of their lives that make people vulnerable: shocks, trends and crises. These factors are not only environmental but also political, economic and, especially in the case of poor women, very often social.

[top] [end]Future plans

A further training manual, entitled Resource Poor Women and Information about Energy is currently being developed and will focus explicitly on the energy assets available to resource-poor women, and the vulnerabilities that they face. It aims to:
  • allow participants to explore the importance of their existing knowledge and the importance of energy resources in increasing security
  • consider the relevance of modern communication technology to them in their quest to be heard
  • allow them to test out reasonable ways in which they can retain control of the vital links through which they can communicate with decision makers.

As the training manual is distributed to partner organisations, an International Gender and Technology network is being set up to share experiences and monitor results. Any organisations interested should contact the author.

[top] [end]References

  1. The ‘Discovering Technologists’ manuals have been piloted in Kenya, Zimbabwe, Peru, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. An international compilation will be published by ITDG.
  2. Sustainable Livelihoods: Lessons from early experience’ Caroline Ashley and Diana Carney, DFID (1999).
  3. Sustainable Livelihoods Guidance Sheets’ DFID (1999)
  4. Appleton H. (ed) Do It Herself, women and technical innovation ITDG Publications 1995.

[top] [end]Download the original article

pdf file link Learning to listen to the poor by Margaret Foster (74 KB)

[top] [end]Contents: Boiling Point 46 - Household energy and the vulnerable

.
.
Household energy and the vulnerable - The handicapped in a disadvantaged community - Strengthening village and neighbourhood organisations - Safety networks for the vulnerable - Women with disabilities - cooking, fires and smoke - Energy needs in a high altitude conflict zone of India - The provision of household energy - Coping mechanisms of internally displaced people in Benguela Province, Angola - AIDS a threat to biomass energy conservation - The hearth - reflections on the needs of women suffering mental illness in India - Identifying barriers to the adoption of specific domestic energy strategies - a new rapid assessment tool - Learning to listen to the poor - Funding for clean technology through the Climate Convention - Looking at household energy provision in a new way - The Sustainable Livelihoods approach - Improved stoves for preventing deforestatio - myth or reality? - The watermill battery charger



edit this page

Page created: 10 July 2007; Last edited: 10 July 2007; Version: 0
Knowledge Bank text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License.

Pagename: LearningToListenToThePoor @HEDON: VQFA